I'm looking at options for a couple cameras to put in/on my chicken coop.
My one and only goal is to be able to view the chickens from my phone when I am away from home...either to check in on them or show them off during a conversation with someone. The indoor camera will be just to check on them during the day/night. Spending $120 on a Starlight camera for the interior is definitely way overkill.
I initially thought about getting the Dahua Starlight Fixed Lens Turret (IPC-HDW4231EM-AS) for the corner of the run to view the chickens when they are outside during the day and I'm at work and the Mini IR Wedge w/SD, Audio (2.8mm, 3.6mm, 6mm): IPC-HDBW4231F-AS for inside the coop. Turns out both cameras are basically the same thing (and the same price) with the only benefit to the Wedge is the form factor. Since I didn't care what it looks like in the coop (and the chickens won't either) I had decided to get two of the 4231 turrets. That is until I stole one of my 5231 Starlight varifocals from my front door and held it up to test the view.
I was probably expecting too much from such close quarters, but they actually do a fairly decent job at getting about 90% of the coverage that i was hoping for. From the outside camera position to the close corner of the shed (the shovel) is 17'. Down the right side of the pen is 22' and down the left side is 24'. The coop is a 10'x12' shed.
This is cutting off about a 3'x3' corner of the run just below the camera. Does/will this matter? Probably not....i guess. The chickens haven't been in here yet as the chicken door will go at the corner just behind where the shovel is leaned up against the coop... This will be installed this weekend. (the more I look at this screen shot, the more i think this camera would work just fine. Its zoomed all the way out, 2.8mm)
Here's a shot with my $35 Hosafe camera (pretty sure it's 3.6mm fixed lens, 1mp)
Now this is viewing the substream, so the main stream (which i can view remotely fairly well) is a little bit wider and much better quality. But... Being 3.6mm it cuts off a significant portion of the run.
The interior of the coop is a different story. I couldn't find a position with the 5231 Starlight (at 2.6mm) that got the FOV that i was hoping for... Even though i shouldn't have been expecting it.
These first two pictures are from the middle of the long side of the 10'x12' shed. I want the wall in this view because the roosts will be on the right side of the window. Either angle cuts off more of the top or bottom than I'd like.
These next two are from the middle of the short side.
Again, more of the top/bottom is cut off than I'd like. This angle in corridor mode was no good either. (But the more i look at it... Going with my original plan this might be the best option)
Now, I realized a few important things during this testing.
1) 99% of the time I will be looking at these cameras I will be viewing the substream from my phone, and probably 80% of the time will be during the day. Spending $240 on a pair of Starlight cameras now seems rather stupid.
2) Four cameras will do the job rather nicely. I'm able to view the full stream of my Hosafe fairly well from my phone. Four POE Hosafe models like the one here will cost me about $180.
3) I really have no idea what cameras will work for me in this situation. I need POE and i want a decent quality but not too decent that i can't view the full stream from my phone.
I just threw the Hosafe in the corner as i was running out of time last night and below you can see the difference between the sub and main streams when viewed from my phone just now.
I'd appreciate any feedback or insight any of you have to offer, whether it be cheap Dahua or ONVIF cameras suggestions or whatever.
@EMPIRETECANDY do you have any $50-$100 2.8mm (or smaller) POE cameras available that might work for me on this situation?
My one and only goal is to be able to view the chickens from my phone when I am away from home...either to check in on them or show them off during a conversation with someone. The indoor camera will be just to check on them during the day/night. Spending $120 on a Starlight camera for the interior is definitely way overkill.
I initially thought about getting the Dahua Starlight Fixed Lens Turret (IPC-HDW4231EM-AS) for the corner of the run to view the chickens when they are outside during the day and I'm at work and the Mini IR Wedge w/SD, Audio (2.8mm, 3.6mm, 6mm): IPC-HDBW4231F-AS for inside the coop. Turns out both cameras are basically the same thing (and the same price) with the only benefit to the Wedge is the form factor. Since I didn't care what it looks like in the coop (and the chickens won't either) I had decided to get two of the 4231 turrets. That is until I stole one of my 5231 Starlight varifocals from my front door and held it up to test the view.
I was probably expecting too much from such close quarters, but they actually do a fairly decent job at getting about 90% of the coverage that i was hoping for. From the outside camera position to the close corner of the shed (the shovel) is 17'. Down the right side of the pen is 22' and down the left side is 24'. The coop is a 10'x12' shed.
This is cutting off about a 3'x3' corner of the run just below the camera. Does/will this matter? Probably not....i guess. The chickens haven't been in here yet as the chicken door will go at the corner just behind where the shovel is leaned up against the coop... This will be installed this weekend. (the more I look at this screen shot, the more i think this camera would work just fine. Its zoomed all the way out, 2.8mm)
Here's a shot with my $35 Hosafe camera (pretty sure it's 3.6mm fixed lens, 1mp)
Now this is viewing the substream, so the main stream (which i can view remotely fairly well) is a little bit wider and much better quality. But... Being 3.6mm it cuts off a significant portion of the run.
The interior of the coop is a different story. I couldn't find a position with the 5231 Starlight (at 2.6mm) that got the FOV that i was hoping for... Even though i shouldn't have been expecting it.
These first two pictures are from the middle of the long side of the 10'x12' shed. I want the wall in this view because the roosts will be on the right side of the window. Either angle cuts off more of the top or bottom than I'd like.
These next two are from the middle of the short side.
Again, more of the top/bottom is cut off than I'd like. This angle in corridor mode was no good either. (But the more i look at it... Going with my original plan this might be the best option)
Now, I realized a few important things during this testing.
1) 99% of the time I will be looking at these cameras I will be viewing the substream from my phone, and probably 80% of the time will be during the day. Spending $240 on a pair of Starlight cameras now seems rather stupid.
2) Four cameras will do the job rather nicely. I'm able to view the full stream of my Hosafe fairly well from my phone. Four POE Hosafe models like the one here will cost me about $180.
3) I really have no idea what cameras will work for me in this situation. I need POE and i want a decent quality but not too decent that i can't view the full stream from my phone.
I just threw the Hosafe in the corner as i was running out of time last night and below you can see the difference between the sub and main streams when viewed from my phone just now.
I'd appreciate any feedback or insight any of you have to offer, whether it be cheap Dahua or ONVIF cameras suggestions or whatever.
@EMPIRETECANDY do you have any $50-$100 2.8mm (or smaller) POE cameras available that might work for me on this situation?
Last edited: