Have you switched from DeepStack to CodeProject.AI? Poll

[gwminor48]

Are most of you going to be ok with CPAI if it ends up going to subscription service? I'm not saying it is going to, just looking at trends and following the money.

 

[actran]

@gwminor48 Always possible. For now, the code is open source and available at GitHub - codeproject/CodeProject.AI-Server: CodeProject SenseAI is a self contained service that software developers can include in, and distribute with, their applications in order to augment their apps with the power of AI.

If CPAI goes commercial, anyone can continue to develop a community version using the codebase.

P.S. A commercial offering is not a bad thing. For some customers, having a commercial product with a support contract is appealing.

 

[wittaj]

@gwminor48 Always possible. For now, the code is open source and available at GitHub - codeproject/CodeProject.AI-Server: CodeProject SenseAI is a self contained service that software developers can include in, and distribute with, their applications in order to augment their apps with the power of AI.

If CPAI goes commercial, anyone can continue to develop a community version using the codebase.

P.S. A commercial offering is not a bad thing. For some customers, having a commercial product with a support contract is appealing.

How is Sentry working out....

 

[abita_brewing]

My CPAI quit working ~2 days ago. This was on a pc that was running for ~3 months.

Reboot - nothing
upgrade bi from x.2 to current - works again

go figure...

 

[BeerNut]

Running Frigate with Coral on server machine to send alerts via MQTT to machine running older version of BI with continuous recording.

 

[nonono]

Is there any compelling reason to switch off of deepstack today? I tried CPAI and had a handful of minor issues and couldn't discern how it was any better so I reverted to DS.

I'm sure eventually I'll have to switch, but is there any compelling reason to feature/performance wise today?

 

[wittaj]

Is there any compelling reason to switch off of deepstack today? I tried CPAI and had a handful of minor issues and couldn't discern how it was any better so I reverted to DS.

I'm sure eventually I'll have to switch, but is there any compelling reason to feature/performance wise today?

If Deepstack works for you, continue with what works.

I am still using Deepstack. The only reason I will switch will be when I decide to try the ANPR module.

 

[concord]

I'm still using DeepStack for now, as I'm only using it on two cameras. When I decide to add more cams for AI, then I may switch to using CodeProject.AI.

 

[tward392]

I switched from Deepstack about a week ago now. Seems like everytime I upgraded Blue Iris to the latest version that Deepstack would start timing out. Usually a couple of computer reboots would take care of it. But when it didn't I decided to give CodeProject.AI. Took a little longer than I thought it would to get it working but it's working just as good if not better than Deepstack. I've noticed the old Deepstack URL is no longer working

DeepStack Documentation!

docs.deepstack.cc

Does that mean it's no longer being supported?

 

[Pentagano]

Actually running both right now.
Deepstack with the AITool for specific objects and codeproject on Blueiris with ipcam combined.
Only been with codeproject for a week now impressed with the integration and functionality. Using curl for telegram notifications

 

[Swampledge]

I just switched to CP this week. Was reluctant to make the change because of difficulties reported here by others, and because DeepStack was satisfying my needs. I was only using DS on a couple of cameras at different times, but was pleased with how it was working. But DS processing times were in the 450 ms range, and would peg the CPU on my 2nd gen i7 that was running 9 cams, so I knew further expansion needed different hardware. A neighborhood incident 3 weeks ago prompted the need to expand my system’s capabilities.

I switched to CP as part of my “new” BI build, on a 7th gen i7. My plan was to get that box up and running in parallel with the original machine, then simply shut off the old one and leave it on the shelf as a backup that could simply be plugged back in and restarted if the new box crashed. About 2 days after starting the test period, I felt confident enough to switch off the machine that has been my BI box for the past 2 years. With CP and the “new” CPU, I’m seeing AI detection times in the 150 ms range, and am using the AI on a couple more cameras.

 

[batch]

wondering if folks are still a fan of CP vs DS? still running DS and aside from all the temp files filling up my pc its been great.

 

[Pentagano]

I ran DS for a good 2 years until Blueiris was more developed with CPAI.
Swapped over to CPAI and been very happy with it so far.
I have codeproject on another server as a container and works great

 

[gwminor48]

I hope the newest version is easier to install. Some people have no problem, it was such an enormous pain in the ass for me to install I went back to Deepstack, taking 5 or 10 minutes to install.

 

[abita_brewing]

I'm with codeproject, but it stops working randomly. I'm considering a timed reboot of nvr each night.

 

[MikeLud1]

I'm with codeproject, but it stops working randomly. I'm considering a timed reboot of nvr each night.

What version CodeProject.AI do you have installed?

 

[hapstabu]

I changed to CPAI from Deep stack about six months ago. I am currently on ver 2.5.1.

Sent from my iPlay_50 using Tapatalk

 

[karlocikovic]

Here’s my two cents...
In few days we will be in 2025, but I'm still using Deepstack version 2022.01.01. GPU version with NVidia 1030 and 2GB VRAM. I'm using community Custom model from MikeLud1. On 4/8 cameras I just confirm person or vehicle for camera ONVIF event (Andy's T5442 variants), and other 4/8 are configured in BlueIris to do triggering with AI. My confirmation times are in range 40-200ms, it depends. This configuration is rock solid for almost 2 years. I couldn't be happier.

 

[batch]

I finally made the switch to code project. have been using deepstack for years. i don't use custom models honestly as i never really dug into it but probably should. I honestly only care about confirmed alerts.
deepstack died on me once again and i finally tested the latest version 2.9.5 of yolov5 6.2. its pretty dang flawless and much faster.

14 cams
i7 9th running on win11 with a rtx 3060ti

 

[MikeLud1]

I finally made the switch to code project. have been using deepstack for years. i don't use custom models honestly as i never really dug into it but probably should. I honestly only care about confirmed alerts.
deepstack died on me once again and i finally tested the latest version 2.9.5 of yolov5 6.2. its pretty dang flawless and much faster.

14 cams
i7 9th running on win11 with a rtx 3060ti

Give Object Detection (YOLOv5 .NET) a try it will be faster then yolov5 6.2.