Newbie Trying to Decide on NVR or BI PC Setup

program2

Young grasshopper
Mar 6, 2016
32
12
I am a complete newbie when it comes to IP cams and recording technology. I am hopeful that I can draw on all the great experience here to arrive at the best solution.

I have had my car broken into at home once in the last couple years, as have a couple neighbors. I live in a "country subdivision" so the houses sit on 2 - 4 acres each. I have a son who is very into soccer and has high-end soccer nets and other training tools in the backyard I want to keep an eye on -- plus monitor my driveway and my front door.

To accomplish this, I am looking at a total of 4 Hikvision 4MP cameras. This may expand to as many as 7 cameras in the future.

I was looking at getting a dedicated PC set-up with Blue Iris, but I am seeing very inconsistent responses on the specs needed for the PC. I am trying to do things properly, but on a budget, so I don't want to run off buying an i7 desktop if that's not what is necessary and I could effectively set up the system with a refurbished Gen 4 i5 system.

That also got me thinking, would it be smarter (and more cost effective?) if I looked at Hikvision or Dahua NVRs? I see most people advise against that.

I definitely appreciate any thoughts the group here can provide -- like I said, I want to do this right, but without tossing away money.

Thanks everyone!
 
The first question you need to be able to answer is whether you want the extra features that come with BI? I am not seeing any comments in your post indicating that you do. Second, are you okay with the time it takes to learn how to set it all up?

If so, I have a 4MP, 3MP, and 2MP running on an HP Elitedesk 800 with a 4th gen i7 that was used on ebay but still has warranty. CPU is under 10% with direct to disk, hardware acceleration, and running as a service. I had a cheap SSD that I installed as the boot drive and I bought a 5TB for storage. So if you add all that up, I spent almost $500 on the BI server.

Read this:

https://www.ipcamtalk.com/showthread.php/7716-Advantages-of-a-NVR-Vs-Blue-Iris-and-a-PC