What Brand / Model to buy? Requirements for Inter house Wifi + Security Cameras

Jun 20, 2019
2
0
Chch NZ
New member here trying to tap into the wealth of knowledge on this forum.

I've been looking at the Ubiquiti line of wifi access points and security cameras. I do like the feature that on a single ethernet cable, you can PoE the wifi acess point and on the 2nd ethernet port, you can connect a security camera. Here's my situation:

I want to share internet from 1 house to the next house that is about 4 houses away so not looking for omnidirectional access points that are ever so popular. The house with the internet is a 2 story house where I have 1 CAT5e cabling that goes to the outside near the TV antenna on the top roof. From there the external access point can be pointed towards the house I want wifi access to (in bridge mode) 4 houses away. At the 2nd house, I want to branch off security cameras to an empty lot next to it. Installing CAT5e cabling is easier as it's a single story house and also want to have cabling to go outside where security cameras will view the empty lot (that is next door). I'm not confident to have a wifi coverage on the entire area and prefer the use of 'bridge' access point wifi, and each house would handle it's on private Wifi network or hard wiring to it's switch.

I've also read that Ubiquiti lacks OVif compatibility and is proprietary. But lots of people have been quite happy with it's UNIFI setup. I really don't want to setup up 2 different systems (ie dedicated security camera system with an NVR or a PC that has to stay on all the time to record the video, and a separate Wifi AP system that uses separate cabling). Though I am a fan of hard wired ethernet when possible.

If you asked me last year, the intent was to only have internet between the 2 houses. But with recent rash of burglaries, I do feel a decent security camera setup should be looked at while doing the wifi installation at the same time. Awaiting for some suggestions. Thank You.
 
Hi there,, you might "forget" about the classic access points (those are really intent for omnidirectional stuff), but Ubiquity also has nanobeams (Ubiquiti Networks - NanoBeam® M). They can go kilometers far, but only in a specific (preferably line-of-sight - no trees, bird nests etc).

However if there's one thing I would advice against, is "digging" yourself in into a proprietary system which does not leverage ANY open system (like onvif). What if support ends on that device, you are obliged to buy something new. And off course Ubiquity (or nest or .. name any other proprietary brand) will have another great (yet closed) system, and then you need a new nvr, and new this and that.

On the other spectrum, you have a VMS like BI, which can work with *any* ONVIF camera, mixed brand etc. However if you want a "bit" of openess, you stick to one brand (like dahua/hik) and use that technology layer (eg. dahua nvr with dahua cams - those NVRs are able to hook up with other ONVIF cams).

Hope this helps!
CC
 
  • Like
Reactions: SouthernYankee
The NanoBeam M appears to only have 1 ethernet port. What I was after is their NanoStation M (NSM models) which has dual ethernet ports (all on PoE). Diagram below:

https://www.securitycameraking.com/.../2014/04/ubiquiti-diagram-point-to-point1.jpg

and I would like the idea of a security camera that runs off the 2nd ethernet port off the access point shown here:
https://prd-www-cdn.ubnt.com/media/images/product-features/nanostationm-feature-dual-ethernet.jpg

This would save me the extra cabling required in places where I can't run cables (I prefer to just use the existing spare ethernet cable. I also like that their 'injector' PoE adapter can be added near the access point end in a daisy chain manner.

I get that with brands like Dahua, you get real professional security monitoring and tend to conform more to a 'security' industry standard like Onvif. If I was rebuilding a house then yes, best to have 2 separate systems (or rather, extra ethernet cabling). I did mention on the single story house I could run my own cabling ; but if there's a way to minimise that messy effort (crawling around the atic space, making mistakes drilling holes in the wrong spots etc.), then it may be a small sacrifice to go with a proprietary setup.

If there's something I missed, please reply.
 
The NanoBeam M appears to only have 1 ethernet port. What I was after is their NanoStation M (NSM models) which has dual ethernet ports (all on PoE). Diagram below:

https://www.securitycameraking.com/.../2014/04/ubiquiti-diagram-point-to-point1.jpg

and I would like the idea of a security camera that runs off the 2nd ethernet port off the access point shown here:
https://prd-www-cdn.ubnt.com/media/images/product-features/nanostationm-feature-dual-ethernet.jpg

This would save me the extra cabling required in places where I can't run cables (I prefer to just use the existing spare ethernet cable. I also like that their 'injector' PoE adapter can be added near the access point end in a daisy chain manner.

Hmm, why save the trouble on this dual-NIC device (which might be expensive? not sure)? What about this nanobeam with one uplink to a closet like this:
61ZNzmZ1EUL._SX425_.jpg

In which you put a small cheapo switch with an uplink to your network and the "local" cam.

Just my 2c.
CC