Does anyone LiveStream their camera on youtube?

FFmpeg is the software behind OBS. OBS gives it a easy to use GUI.
 
  • Like
Reactions: looney2ns
@area651 is your livestream working fine at the moment? I am using Synology's Live Broadcast too, and I think I have the right settings now for YouTube. My stream is live for more than 24 hours now, and I keep my fingers crossed it will stay on 24/7.

I am pretty sure it is a combination of camera settings (mainly FPS, bit rate type, bit rate and I frame interval) and the way YouTube receives those settings while using Live Broadcast with your Synology NAS.

The cam I use for livestreaming the nest box is a Dahua DH-SD1A203T-GN by the way.
 
I've tried it from BI before but not for too long a period of time. How long before you guys have seen the stream die?
 
mikeynags said:
I've tried it from BI before but not for too long a period of time. How long before you guys have seen the stream die?
Click to expand...
Not an exact duration, it varied every time but mostly after a couple of hours. I never succeeded for more than 10 hours until now. At first I thought it had something to do with my ISP, but that wasn't the case.
 
About the same for me. I may have made it for a little longer but don't think mine ever lasted for a full day.
 
I have many livestreams running for myself and for customers. Several have been running continuously for over a year with no intervention by me. The only way I have found to do this is to monitor the stream and streaming server constantly by using Linux for the server, FFmpeg for the encoding and python scripting to monitor the stream every few seconds. I check the outgoing bps, ping the camera IP address, ping a known good internet address, monitor the power, CPU temperature and housing temperature continuously . Depending on what goes wrong the system will automatically restart FFmpeg, reboot the router or cycle power to the camera. If it can't correct itself quickly then a "We'll be right back" image is streamed to YouTube Live to preserve the live stream so it won't be dropped by YouTube. Then, the system keeps trying to fix itself. If it can't and there is still an internet connection, the python script sends me a text message. In almost all of the live streams this is all done with a cheap raspberry pi 3. My current project is the figure out the YouTube API. I'm hoping this will give me a better way to monitor and control the stream after it leaves the server.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alanthecolettes-com and looney2ns
I can understand why you need/want to do all of that in your case given where yours tend to be. In my case I was just trying to stream one of the cams that I have running at my home and most of the monitoring/recovery is kind of built into that. i.e., I have a cam that I'm streaming to BI otherwise and could see that it's running fine there, I know that my Internet is good and have plenty of upload capacity, etc. I could see that everything seemed to be running fine. But my stream still would be dropped after a while.

I think I looked on the YouTube side but didn't see any settings beyond just that required to make the connection. Are there particular settings that you use for the stream itself that work better/worse?
 
YouTube pretty much spells out what it wants to see from the remote RTMP encoder. Choose live encoder settings, bitrates, and resolutions - YouTube Help I set the camera parameters and write the FFmpeg script around their recommendations. And then watch the "STREAM HEALTH" in YouTube studio. It will tell you if there is something it doesn't like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alanthecolettes-com, looney2ns and Mike A.
I guess my point was, all that is needed to have a reliable YouTube Live Stream is a cheap Raspberry Pi, some free software that is included with the Raspberry Pi OS and a single line script. No need for an NVR, BI or any other peripherals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 78suited, looney2ns and CanCuba
TRLcam said:
I guess my point was, all that is needed to have a reliable YouTube Live Stream is a cheap Raspberry Pi, some free software that is included with the Raspberry Pi OS and a single line script. No need for an NVR, BI or any other peripherals.
Click to expand...
True that, but I already use a Synology NAS and with Surveillance Station there's a tool called Live Broadcast for sending your livestream to YouTube, and that works pretty well if you use the right settings. Because of the limitations I will experiment with OBS Studio in the near future. With OBS I can use nice widgets and lower thirds for example.
 
OK, got the bluebird box live streaming on YouTube about 90 minutes ago @ 1415 hr CT; the birds began bringing in some straw this morning so just in time, I reckon.
I used vMix to stream with a VLC plug-in to stream from BI; used BI so I could have a decent date/time overlay (the cam's overlay is teensy, practically invisible). Besides, I might add the temp overlay later.

vMix is a 60 day trial and if I don't get the audio working OK I may go back to the free OBS....IOW, it's a work in progress.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cyberwolf_uk, CanCuba, 78suited and 3 others
looney2ns said:
Your birds need to get with it. :p
View attachment 156213
Click to expand...
For sure....this couple has been checking the house inside 2-3 times a day, every day for 2 weeks now and finally decided just this morning to make a down payment on it with a few straws, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smilingreen and looney2ns
  • Like
Reactions: looney2ns
I posted that thread a long time ago, and would you believe its still on my list of things to do :lmao:

I ended up putting the Sercomm RC4551 in the garage where its been working well, now I need a second for the bird feeder...
 
@TonyR I'm watching the stream now and no birds. Please put the birds back in the box
 
  • Haha
Reactions: looney2ns, TonyR, TRLcam and 1 other person
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom