So I got a reply from the software company. And this is what I was told.
" Each license or maintenance key includes 1 year of updates. You have installed a version that's "too new" for your current maintenance. Unfortunately at this time due to a server failure, we don't ourselves have access to any older versions, but perhaps you have saved an older installer that you may use if you don't choose to renew maintenance."
Out of frustration, I just paid the 36 bucks since a week of typing the license key numerous times per day was too annoying. After all, it is a great product. I did not save all the installation files so I was kind of beat anyway. I don't understand how I can have 2 new of a product. If my subscription was expired, how did I get it?