The NVR with POE is better than Without POE.???
This question is asked a lot here. IMO, it's not a 'it's better' type question. There are pros and cons, but neither is right or wrong, or better or worse, it just depends on your priorities.
With the POE version, you are limited in what you can do and how convenient it is to do things but you will be up and running faster, with less gear, but a louder (unknown just how much louder it is) nvr. The NON poe version is for the more advanced user that knows what they're doing and is willing to spend slightly more for the extra gear to get things setup just right. In return for the extra setup, they get a quieter more flexible system with more options.
This is the way I look at it:
Get the POE version:
1) you want to save every dollar possible. it is the cheapest way to get 16 POE ports
2) Ease of setup
3) Want to be absolutely sure the cameras are on their own network
4) Are NOT technically skilled to setup/configure other switches, etc
5) Can deal with having to either replace the whole nvr or purchase poe injectors 'if' the built in POE fails
6) Can deal with a louder NVR due to the extra fan
7) Can deal with unplugging cameras from the nvr and into another switch so you can configure them from another pc for more advanced features like IVS, etc
Get the NON-POE version:
1) You want flexiblity and are willing to spend slightly more money for other switches (with POE) or will power the cameras directly via 12v plugs
2) Are willing to setup switches, managed switches, poe, 12v power, etc and thus can access cameras directly without having to unplug cameras.
3) A quieter nvr
For the record, I ordered the non-POE version and then bought a managed switch and an 8 port POE switch. A lot of my existing cameras positions already have 12v power and I'll use POE for the new positions.