New System Set Up

a1topgun

a1topgun

n3wb
Sep 24, 2019
12
4
NE US
Newbie here. I have set up a few webcams at our local small airport so I have some (very little) experience. We are building a new terminal building at the airport and the manager asked me to set up a new security camera system with 7 – 8 cameras. Looking at Amcrest, Lorex, or Dahua system with a DVR/NVR. POE and Open Source are required and I will use Blue Iris.

One question I can’t find an answer to is do I need a DVR/NVR or can I just dedicate a computer as a server?

I would appreciate any comments and or gottcha’s in setting up a system like this.

Thank in advance to any and all who respond.

Ron
 
+1 above - Blue Iris/computer is basically an NVR. You don't need both.

What kind of airport is it? Does it get any federal or FAA funds?

If so, you probably need NDAA compliant gear and that throws out anything Dahua (they make Lorex and Amcrest) or Hikvision, among others.

In any event, I would look into the specifics of NDAA and make sure even a private airport wouldn't need to comply.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alastairstevenson and JDreaming
wittaj said:
+1 above - Blue Iris/computer is basically an NVR. You don't need both.

What kind of airport is it? Does it get any federal or FAA funds?

If so, you probably need NDAA compliant gear and that throws out anything Dahua (they make Lorex and Amcrest) or Hikvision, among others.

In any event, I would look into the specifics of NDAA and make sure even a private airport wouldn't need to comply.
Click to expand...

It is a small GA airport. FAA funding for new terminal building, but specified security only applies to gate and building entry locks. I will check the NDAA but I don't think it will apply.
 
a1topgun said:
Newbie here. I have set up a few webcams at our local small airport so I have some (very little) experience. We are building a new terminal building at the airport and the manager asked me to set up a new security camera system with 7 – 8 cameras. Looking at Amcrest, Lorex, or Dahua system with a DVR/NVR. POE and Open Source are required and I will use Blue Iris.

One question I can’t find an answer to is do I need a DVR/NVR or can I just dedicate a computer as a server?

I would appreciate any comments and or gottcha’s in setting up a system like this.

Thank in advance to any and all who respond.

Ron
Click to expand...

Requirements ..

PoE => thus NVR .. IP ethernet

Open Source .. not certain how to fill this requirement here ..

NVR .. blue iris VMS running on a PC will fill this functionality .. some nvrs have poe ports .. so you will need a PoE switch ..
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming

www.ebay.com

HP EliteDesk 800 G4 SFF Intel Core i5-8500 3.00GHz 8GB RAM 1TB HDD | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for HP EliteDesk 800 G4 SFF Intel Core i5-8500 3.00GHz 8GB RAM 1TB HDD at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!
www.ebay.com



www.ebay.com

Western Digital Purple Pro 10TB Surveillance Hard Drive 3.5" WD101PURP | eBay

Western Digital Purple PRO 10TB, Internal Hard Drive, WD101PURP, 3.5"/256 MB/7200 RPM. WD Purple PRO Surveillance. WD Purple Pro drives also feature enterprise-class performance, data integrity and drive reliability, especially in larger-scale systems and enclosures where operational vibration...
www.ebay.com
 
As an eBay Associate IPCamTalk earns from qualifying purchases.
As an Amazon Associate IPCamTalk earns from qualifying purchases.
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming
mat200 said:
Requirements ..

PoE => thus NVR .. IP ethernet

Open Source .. not certain how to fill this requirement here ..

NVR .. blue iris VMS running on a PC will fill this functionality .. some nvrs have poe ports .. so you will need a PoE switch ..
Click to expand...

Yes, I was thinking along the lines of a NVR for the POE ports and not having to run a separate POE switch. The town will likely provide a desktop for the server, probably Windows. I would prefer Linux, I use Ubuntu on my personal machine.
Is there a Linux distro that works best for Blue Iris?
 
Yes you will need an external PoE switch if using BI
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming
You dont need an NVR AND BI. They are both systems to record and mange your video

PC running BI + PoE switch
Or
NVR with built in PoE switch
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming and a1topgun
An NVR and Blue Iris/computer are both considered a VMS system.

You only need one or the other. Although some run both as a redundant system.

But for either to work, they will need to be on 24/7 and have storage drives in them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming and a1topgun
I am not sure how deep this goes, but my first brush would be it would have to be NDAA compliant since the airport receives federal funds even if the camera isn't being used on the terminal receiving funds Folks are saying even parking structures at airports need NDAA compliant. You would hate to spend money to then find out you are out of compliance.

Quote: "At first glance it may seem that the NDAA ban only applies to federal agencies, however, there are a number of public entities that rely on federal funds in the form of grants. Airports are one of these entities.

While most airports are state or city-owned, many receive federal funding for capital improvements through the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which operates under the Federal Airport Act."

www.parking.net

What Does the 2019 NDAA Ban Mean for Airports and the Parking Industry?

Does Your Airport Parking Guidance System Comply with the New NDAA Restrictions on Telecommunication/Video Surveillance Equipment Manufactured in China? The Jo
www.parking.net www.parking.net
 
  • Like
Reactions: bigredfish and JDreaming
OK, I think i've got the server / NVD part straight.

As far as NDAA, that is a rabbit hole I don't want to go down. We tried to get the FAA to inculde a security system in the bid spec. and they specificly stated they would not allow the funds to be used for cameras. The FAA would not fund a conference room in the new builing. You should see our very spacious "Pilot's Lounge" with the big table and nice chairs! The town is funding the camera system and the NDAA states no government grant funds can be used for cameras. And on top of that almost all afforable camreas are made / sourced from China. As far as I know there are a couple of local airports that had government funds to renovate their facilities and they installed camera systems using town funds. I don't think they were told to tear out their systems.

Now back to Linux Open Source management software, I have set up some cameras using ZoneMinder and it works, but I find it not very intuitive. Anyone have thoughts on Linux Open Source management software?
 
I would think town funds would require NDAA, but what do I know LOL. Just pointing it out. Keep in mind I am not a fan of NDAA, but don't want you coming back here saying you got bad advice if they are needed.

So you have jumped from NVR to Blue Iris and now to Linux open source lol.

NVR and BI are not open source, so if that is a requirement then toss those two out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JDreaming and a1topgun
Here's one source of NDAA compliant cameras: Shop Security Cameras, Recorders & Complete Systems

As for software, there are several linux-based NVR programs. Shinobi comes to mind.

You'll get much better community support at this forum if you run Windows and Blue Iris though. It can run in a virtual machine just fine if you prefer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: looney2ns, a1topgun and JDreaming
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom